What are the key takeaways?
- FSRA flags fees demanded before closing, extra charges for late payments, offers based only on property value, fast power-of-sale terms and unrealistic exits.
- The Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre warns about upfront fees, promises of approval regardless of credit, instant approval and requests for payment by e-transfer or prepaid card.
- Check every person and brokerage against your provincial regulator's licence lookup before sharing documents or paying anything.
- A red flag is a reason to pause, ask in writing and get independent legal advice, not necessarily a reason to panic.
What warning signs appear in the offer itself?
Ontario's regulator, FSRA, publishes a short checklist for people considering a private mortgage. Its warning signs are useful anywhere in Canada because they describe the structure of a risky deal rather than any one province's rules.
None of these items is proof of wrongdoing on its own. Each one is a point where a borrower can lose money or options if the terms are not understood, so each deserves a direct question and a written answer before you go further.
- Fees demanded before closing. Money asked for before the loan funds deserves close scrutiny; see advance-fee loan scams.
- Extra interest or fees for late payments. Read the default clauses closely; federal law limits some charges on mortgage arrears, as explained in Interest Act section 8.
- An offer based only on the property's value, with no real look at whether you can afford the payments.
- A power of sale process that starts very quickly after a missed payment.
- An unrealistic exit strategy, such as a refinance or sale that depends on optimistic assumptions.
What warning signs come from the people and the process?
How someone behaves often tells you as much as what they offer. The Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre (CAFC) describes common signs of loan fraud, and several of them overlap with what a borrower might hear when shopping for private money.
- A request for an upfront fee before any loan is advanced. The CAFC notes that this is illegal in most provinces.
- Promises of approval no matter what your credit history looks like.
- Instant approval, without documents, an appraisal or any review of your situation.
- A request to pay by e-transfer, through a money service business, or with a prepaid card.
- Someone who cannot or will not give the licence details of the individual and brokerage, or whose name does not appear on the provincial lookup.
- Pressure to sign quickly, or resistance when you ask how much time you have to take the documents to a lawyer. FSRA tells borrowers to ask that question directly.
What warning signs show up in the paperwork?
Documents that are vague, incomplete or inconsistent are a problem even when everyone involved is honest, because the paperwork is what will be enforced. Look for these issues in the commitment letter and mortgage terms.
- Fees mentioned verbally that do not appear in writing, or a total that does not match the list of fees.
- A rate shown without how it is compounded, or costs quoted only by the month; see Interest Act section 4 for why yearly figures matter.
- No cost-of-borrowing statement or APR where your province requires one; see cost of borrowing disclosure.
- Blank spaces, missing schedules, or a request to sign documents you have not been allowed to keep a copy of.
- Terms that differ from what you were told, such as a shorter term, a different lender name or an added prepaid interest holdback.
What warning signs show up in the numbers?
Some offers are entirely legitimate yet still cost far more than the headline rate suggests. Fees deducted from the advance, a short term and a discharge fee at payout can combine to push the all-in cost well above the contract rate. The worked example below shows an illustrative nine-month Nova Scotia loan where a 10.5% contract rate becomes an all-in APR of about 16.9% once fees are counted.
Very high all-in costs also raise a legal question. Since January 1, 2025, the Criminal Code's criminal interest rate is an APR above 35%, and fees count toward it; see the criminal interest rate guide. Run any offer through the true cost calculator at its real term, and if the result surprises you, take it to a lawyer.
What does the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre warn about?
The Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre (CAFC) lists warning signs of loan scams. Any one of them is reason to stop; several together should end the conversation.
- A request for an upfront fee. The CAFC notes that this is illegal in most provinces.
- Promises of approval regardless of your credit. A lender that does not care whether you can repay is not behaving like a lender.
- Instant approval, without documents, an appraisal or a review of your circumstances.
- Payment requested by e-transfer, through a money service business, or by prepaid card, methods that can be hard to reverse.
How do legitimate private mortgage fees differ?
Legitimate private mortgages do involve fees, sometimes significant ones, so the existence of a fee is not the test. What matters is when the fee is payable, to whom, how, and whether it is disclosed in writing. In a typical legitimate loan, the lender fee, broker fee and other costs are set out in writing in the commitment and deducted from the advance on closing day, so the borrower never sends money ahead to anyone.
Regulators have spoken to timing directly. FSRA lists fees demanded before closing among the warning signs for private mortgage borrowers. FSRA also states that in Ontario a brokerage may charge an upfront fee or retainer only for loans above $400,000, that it must be paid directly to the brokerage rather than to an agent or broker, and that it cannot be paid in cash. Nova Scotia's consumer page says fees cannot be charged until the borrower has a written funding commitment and a copy of the signed mortgage. Rules in other provinces were not verified for this guide, so ask your regulator.
Use the true cost calculator to see what a legitimate fee structure costs, and private mortgage fees explained to understand what each one is for.
What should you do when you spot a red flag?
Treat a warning sign as a prompt to slow down and verify. These steps work whatever the flag turns out to be.
- Stop. Do not pay anything, sign anything or send further personal documents until the issue is resolved.
- Check the individual and the brokerage on your province's licence lookup; see provincial licence lookup directory.
- Ask your questions in writing and keep the replies. The printable question list is a good starting list.
- Take the offer and documents to your own lawyer before going further; see independent legal advice.
- If you believe you have been targeted by fraud, contact local police. In Ontario, FSRA says victims of mortgage fraud may also file a complaint with FSRA; in other provinces, contact your regulator.
What if you have already paid?
Act quickly, and do not let embarrassment slow you down. Scammers rely on victims staying quiet, and some may come back with a second approach, such as an offer to recover your money for a fee.
Contact your bank or the payment provider you used and explain what happened. Report the matter to local police; FSRA says victims of mortgage fraud should contact police and may file a complaint with FSRA, and in other provinces you can contact your regulator. The CAFC's loan scam page has further guidance. Keep every message, receipt and document, and stop all contact with the scammer. If any documents were registered against your property, speak to a lawyer straight away. For broader warning signs, see private mortgage red flags.
A commitment with fees not itemized, no net advance stated, no disclosure statement and three months of interest held back.
| Loan | $200,000 second mortgage12-month term, interest-only |
|---|---|
| Rate | 11.99%compounded monthly |
| Fees | $13,000lender 3%, broker 2%, other $3,000, deducted from the advance |
| Property | $600,000$250,000 first mortgage ahead; combined LTV 75.0% |
| Clauses | 3 months' interest prepaid |
| Credit actually advanced | $181,005loan minus every deducted charge |
| APR on credit advanced | 19.29%Criminal Code s.347 limit: 35% |
| If repaid at month 3 | 40.59%fees spread over fewer months |
| All-in effective annual cost | 21.09% |
| Cost of the term | $36,980interest plus fees; $200,000 still owed at maturity |
| Analyzer verdict | Get it reviewed6 points to raise |
- serious If repaid early, the APR could pass 35% (40.6% at month 3)
- serious $13,000 in fees are not itemized
- serious No written cost-of-borrowing disclosure yet
- Check Ask for the net amount you will receive
Open this example in the commitment analyzer →Computed by this site's commitment analyzer (Criminal Code s.347, Interest Act ss.6, 8, 10). Illustrative terms, not an offer.
What does this mean for you?
- Check the person and the brokerage on the licence lookup before you share documents or pay anything.
- Never send money before a written commitment, and never by wire, gift card or crypto; legitimate fees come off the advance at closing.
- Report suspected loan scams to the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre and your provincial regulator.
What do people ask most?
What are the warning signs of a bad private mortgage?
FSRA lists fees demanded before closing, extra interest or fees for late payments, offers based only on property value, a power of sale process that starts very quickly, and an unrealistic exit strategy.
Is it normal to pay a fee before a private mortgage closes?
Fees demanded before closing are on FSRA's list of warning signs, and the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre notes that upfront loan fees are illegal in most provinces. Ask exactly what any fee is for, check the licence of the person asking, and get legal advice first.
How do I check whether a mortgage broker is licensed?
Use the official licence lookup for your province, typing the regulator's address yourself. The provincial mortgage broker regulators guide lists the verified lookups.
Where do I report private mortgage fraud?
Contact local police. In Ontario, FSRA says victims of mortgage fraud may also file a complaint with FSRA; elsewhere, contact your provincial regulator.
Is it legal for a lender to ask for a fee before giving me a loan?
The Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre notes that upfront loan fees are illegal in most provinces. For mortgages, specific rules vary; Ontario and Nova Scotia have their own limits on when fees can be charged, so check with your provincial regulator.
Which primary sources back this page?
This guide is general education for Canadians, not financial, legal or tax advice. Figures in examples are illustrative, not offers or market rates. Rules change; confirm current requirements with a licensed mortgage professional and a lawyer (or notary in Quebec).

