What are the key takeaways?
- Where you are in the process matters: an active proposal or undischarged bankruptcy raises different questions than a completed one.
- Speak with the trustee who administered your file before taking on new secured debt while the process is still open.
- A private lender focuses on equity, so the loan-to-value and a falling-price stress test deserve close attention.
- The goal is a short, planned stay in private financing while credit is rebuilt, not a long-term arrangement.
Why does proposal versus bankruptcy matter?
In a consumer proposal, a debtor offers creditors a repayment arrangement and keeps making payments over an agreed period. In a bankruptcy, assets may be dealt with by a trustee and the debtor is later discharged. The details, including how a home and its equity are treated, depend on federal insolvency law, provincial exemptions and the facts of each file. This site does not summarize those rules; your trustee and a lawyer are the right people to explain how they apply to you.
For borrowing purposes, the practical difference is timing and control. Someone in an active proposal may be thinking about paying it out early with a lump sum. Someone in an undischarged bankruptcy faces more restrictions and should not assume any new borrowing is permitted. Someone already discharged or with a completed proposal is generally in the simplest position to explore a mortgage.
| Your situation | First question to ask | Who to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Active consumer proposal | Would paying the proposal out early change anything for me, and is new secured borrowing allowed now? | Your trustee |
| Undischarged bankruptcy | Am I permitted to borrow, and what happens to equity in my home? | Your trustee and a lawyer |
| Proposal completed or bankruptcy discharged | What do my credit reports show, and what would a bank need to see to lend again? | A licensed mortgage professional |
| Behind on the existing mortgage too | What are my options and timelines with the current lender? | A lawyer; see the arrears guide |
How will a private lender view your file?
A private lender lends against the property first. That makes equity the central number. The lender will look at the current value, any mortgage already registered, and how much room is left. Some lenders also care a great deal about why the insolvency happened and what has changed since, such as a job recovered, a business closed or a divorce settled.
Expect questions about the existing mortgage payment history, property tax status and any remaining judgments or liens. Arrears on property tax or the first mortgage can be a bigger concern to a lender than the insolvency itself, because they affect the security directly. If you are already behind, read private mortgage arrears and default first.
How much equity cushion do you have?
Because a private loan here leans on equity, a drop in property value hurts twice: it reduces the lender's comfort and it shrinks your own safety margin. Before agreeing to any amount, run the numbers at today's value and at a lower value. The example below uses the LTV and equity calculator to test a second mortgage behind an existing first.
In that example, the combined loan-to-value is 71.3% today, but a 10% fall in value would push it to 79.2%. That matters when it is time to refinance with a bank, because a lower appraisal could leave you short of what a conventional lender will advance. Loan-to-value in private lending explains why lenders cap the ratio.
What does it cost, and what should you weigh it against?
Private money is priced for risk, and fees may be deducted from the advance. On a smaller second mortgage, fixed costs such as legal and appraisal weigh even more heavily as a percentage of the loan. Use the true cost calculator with any offer you receive so you can see the effective annual cost, not just the contract rate.
Then compare that cost with the alternatives. If the purpose is to pay out a proposal early, ask your trustee what the remaining payments would cost if you simply continued them. If the purpose is to consolidate new debts that built up after the insolvency, read private mortgage debt consolidation, which covers the risks of moving unsecured balances onto your home.
How do you rebuild toward a conventional lender?
The private mortgage should come with an end date you believe in. Work backward from it. What would a bank or B lender need to see by then? Typically that includes re-established credit with on-time payments, stable verifiable income and enough equity at a conservative appraisal.
Practical steps include checking both credit bureau reports for errors once your proposal is complete or you are discharged, keeping every payment on time, and using a small secured credit product responsibly if a mortgage professional suggests it. How to get back to a bank lays out the process step by step.
When could a private loan make things worse?
Insolvency usually follows a period when income did not cover obligations. A private mortgage adds a new, often higher, monthly payment and a firm maturity date. If the reasons behind the original financial trouble are still present, borrowing against the home can turn a manageable problem into one that puts the home itself at risk.
Pause and get a second opinion if any of the following sound familiar. None of them automatically rules out a private loan, but each one makes the exit harder and the cost of a delay higher.
- The monthly payment on the new loan would only be affordable if income rises or other costs fall.
- There is no specific date or event that would let you refinance with a conventional lender.
- The loan would leave little equity, so even a modest price decline could block a refinance.
- New unsecured debt has built up since the proposal or discharge, and the spending pattern behind it has not changed.
- Someone is pressing you to sign quickly or to skip independent legal advice.
What should you do before you sign anything?
Ask for the commitment in writing, with every fee listed. Check whether the loan is open or closed, what happens at maturity, and whether there are fees for renewal or late payment. Get independent legal advice; a lawyer who acts only for you can flag terms that could become a problem if your plans slip. The printable question list gives you a list to work through.
If the numbers are tight, a non-profit credit counselling organization or your trustee may be able to talk through alternatives before you add secured debt. Whatever you decide, keep copies of every document, and diarize the maturity date and the date by which you plan to start the refinance conversation.
A $60,000 second at 12.99% behind a $310,000 first on a $520,000 home, used to finish a proposal early.
| Loan | $60,000 second mortgage12-month term, interest-only |
|---|---|
| Rate | 12.99%compounded monthly |
| Fees | $4,500lender 3%, broker 2%, other $1,500, deducted from the advance |
| Property | $520,000$310,000 first mortgage ahead; combined LTV 71.2% |
| Credit actually advanced | $55,500loan minus every deducted charge |
| APR on credit advanced | 21.39%Criminal Code s.347 limit: 35% |
| If repaid at month 3 | 45.28%fees spread over fewer months |
| All-in effective annual cost | 23.61% |
| Cost of the term | $12,294interest plus fees; $60,000 still owed at maturity |
| Analyzer verdict | Get it reviewed2 points to raise |
- serious If repaid early, the APR could pass 35% (45.3% at month 3)
- Check Fees add 9.8% a year on top of the rate
Open this example in the commitment analyzer →Computed by this site's commitment analyzer (Criminal Code s.347, Interest Act ss.6, 8, 10). Illustrative terms, not an offer.
What does this mean for you?
- On a small loan, fixed costs and percentage fees weigh more; check the APR on the cash advanced before anything else.
- Time the term to when your report clears, and confirm the dates with Equifax and TransUnion.
- Compare a private second with a licensed insolvency trustee's options; paying out a proposal early isn't always worth the cost.
What do people ask most?
Can I get a mortgage while I am still in a consumer proposal?
Some private lenders may consider it, mainly based on equity, but you should first ask your trustee whether new secured borrowing is permitted and how it would affect your proposal.
Can I use a private mortgage to pay off my consumer proposal early?
It may be possible. Compare the full cost of the private loan with simply completing your remaining proposal payments, and confirm the steps with your trustee.
How long after bankruptcy can I get a bank mortgage?
It depends on the lender, your credit since discharge, income and equity. A licensed mortgage professional can tell you what specific lenders would currently require.
Is a private mortgage after bankruptcy a good idea?
It can be a useful bridge when there is a clear, realistic exit and enough equity. It can also be costly and risky if it only delays a problem, so get independent legal and financial advice.
This guide is general education for Canadians, not financial, legal or tax advice. Figures in examples are illustrative, not offers or market rates. Rules change; confirm current requirements with a licensed mortgage professional and a lawyer (or notary in Quebec).

